Prepare four documents (5-7 pages total) that advise a county board of advisers on matters related to a proposed tax rate, participative vs. authoritative budgets, methods of governmental financial reporting, and a cost-variance analysis.
This assessment will give you the opportunity to act as the comptroller for an imaginary Caroline County. As the comptroller, you will prepare and submit documents to the County Board that explain and demonstrate the unique accounting methods used by a county government, including the calculation and proposal of a tax rate.
Demonstration of Proficiency
By successfully completing this assessment, you will demonstrate your proficiency in the following course competencies through corresponding scoring guide criteria:
- Competency 1: Apply advanced accounting techniques to organizational situations.
- Explain dual government financial reports, including their names, contents, and the reason for the two sets.
- Competency 2: Analyze budgeting practices in organizations.
- Analyze revenues and expenditures for a governmental entity.
- Competency 3: Apply appropriate budgeting techniques for planning, executing, and controlling. Competency 4: Apply quantitative models to create and manage budgets and forecasts and evaluate budget performance.
- Present tax rate necessary to balance revenues and expenditures for a governmental entity.
- Compare participative budgets and authoritative budgets, including the advantages and disadvantages of each.
- Create a budget based on estimated tax rate.
- Explain how an overall variance is divided into a cost variance and a volume variance.
- Competency 5: Communicate in a manner that is professional and consistent with expectations for members of the business professions.
- Communicate in a manner that is professional and consistent with expectations for members of the business professions.
For this assessment, you will act as the comptroller for an imaginary Caroline County. The current county board of supervisors is mostly new, so they will need a lot of guidance. One board member has requested an explanation for the two sets of financial reports used in government accounting. The board will also need recommendations on whether to approach the budget using an authoritative or participative approach. The most important item will be setting an appropriate tax rate for next year that takes into account the possible purchase of 6 new school busses, but the board has also requested a cost-variance analysis to explain food overages incurred during a recent bicentennial celebration at the county seat in Clarksville.
You are the comptroller of the fictional Caroline County.
For this assessment, your comptroller tasks will include preparing and submitting four different documents:
Document 1: Tax Rate Proposal and Budget (1–2 pages, not counting support documents and associated schedules)
In preparation for the annual meeting with the county board of supervisors, you will present a tax rate proposal and associated budget. To do so, you will need to:
- Analyze revenues and expenditures for Caroline County.
- Present a tax rate for the coming year that will balance revenues and expenditures in Caroline County.
- Create a budget based on the estimated tax rate.
Data relevant to your proposal and budget:
- Last year’s tax rate of 1.25% of assessed value of real estate was based on a budget requiring spending of $10,000,000 total from all sources.
- One-fourth of that came from taxes on real estate.
- The total assessed value of the property in the county was $200,000,000.
- Since the last tax rate was set:
- The county’s property has been appraised at an overall increase of 2 percent. This does not include the real estate of 15 new business at a total of $4,000,000 in assessed value or the addition of a new housing development adding a total of $10,000,000 in assessed value.
- New regulations from the state will add $500,000 to the amount needed by county schools. The state will not pay for any of this $500,000.
- The county would like to know the feasibility of purchasing 6 new school buses costing $200,000 USD each.
When preparing this tax rate proposal and budget (1–2 pages) for submission to the supervisors, include all relevant supporting documents and other information, such as:
- Estimated assessed value of all property in the county.
- Forecasted additions to the county surplus if the supervisors adopt your recommendation.
Document 2: Participative versus Authoritative Budget Recommendation (1–2 pages)
The county board of supervisors is currently debating whether the heads of the county departments should have more input into the budget preparation process than they have had in previous years. In other words, the board is debating whether to move to a more participative budgeting process. Write a report (1–2 pages) for presentation at the next board meeting that discusses the difference between a participative budget and an authoritative budget. Include the advantages and disadvantages of each.
Document 3: Government Financial Reporting Explanation (2 pages)
One of the newly elected members of the county board of supervisors is looking at last year’s Comprehensive Annual Financial Report and has noticed that it appears to contain two sets of financial reports instead of the one that he is used to seeing for business enterprises. He has asked you to explain this to him. Write an email (2 pages) that discusses the two sets of financial reports, including their names, their contents, and the reason that there are two sets.
Document 4: Cost-Variance Analysis (1 page)
A party was held to celebrate the bicentennial of Clarksville, the county seat of Caroline County. Six-hundred attendees were estimated, but 700 arrived. The food and entertainment budget was $6,000, but the actual costs were $7,500. The overall spending variance was $1,500 ($7,500 – $6,000 = $1,500). Using flexible budgeting techniques and variance analysis, write a report (1 page) that explains how this $1,500 overall variance is divided into a cost variance and a volume variance. Include your calculations and conclusions to present at the next board meeting.
For the sake of this assessment, imagine that all four of the documents you prepare will be archived in the county board’s records. Remember, too, that the prompt and effective decisions of the board will depend on the clarity, accuracy, and readability of these documents. You want each of them to be clear, well-organized, and readable.
- Communication: Communicate in a manner that is professional and consistent with the needs and expectations of county board supervisors and other interested stakeholders. Assume the board of supervisors expect original work. Your writing must be free of errors that detract from the overall message.
- All four documents are professional documents and should therefore follow the corresponding MBA Academic and Professional Document Guidelines, including single-spaced paragraphs.
- Resources: No outside resources are required.
- Length: See specific lengths for each individual document in the Requirements section above.
- Font and font size: Times New Roman, 12 pt.
Faculty will use the scoring guide to review your deliverables as if s/he were on the board of directors. Review the scoring guide prior to developing and submitting your assessment.